Contractors v Employees
An on-going difficulty we see New Zealand businesses facing is knowing whether their workers are classed as employees or contractors. It is an important distinction to make as the rights and privileges allowed to each are very different and only an employee will have the protection of the Employment Relations Act.
One of the first traps employers fall into is believing that their intention will provide the answer. While the Employment Court and Tribunal will take this into consideration, it is by no means the deciding factor. Just because you intend for your worker to be an employee or a contractor does not make them so. Similarly, the language used by either party or the wording used in contracts does not provide a definitive answer either, calling your worker a contractor will not necessarily make them one.
The answer to the question comes from determining “the real nature of the relationship”. As well as taking industry practice into consideration, there are 3 tests which the court will look at.
The control test asks questions relating to if the worker or the employer sets the hours of work, the work content and the level that the employer supervises the worker. The assumption is that the more control an employer has over the worker; the more likely they are to be an employee.
The integration test asks whether or not the worker is part and parcel of the organisation and whether or not they are necessary for the running of the business. The less integral the worker, the more likely they are to be a contractor.
The fundamental test looks at whether or not the worker is able to make a profit for themselves, if they are able to bring in independent contractors and who would be liable if something went wrong. These questions help determine if the worker is in business on their own account. Someone in business on their own account will more than likely be a contractor.
These tests are not clear cut and are by no means an exhaustive list. This highlights the importance of making sure that both parties are in agreement from the beginning and that the real nature of the relationship is in line with the intention of the parties and the contractual language used.
For further information please contact Jane Traynor on jane.traynor@slaw.co.nz

